
An email from my Grand-Uncle(pictured here) who lives in Germany and my response...
Dear Kurt,
Bertl's calendar reminds us of your anniversary and I take this as an excuse to find out about you. But, oh no: first our heartiest congratulations for having reached this advanced age (one should not take it for granted) and then our best wishes for the next year to come, Obiwan Kenobi, Yoda, bread crumbs and all. Where have they led you to ? Julie's cryptic remarks about founding a new church had left us puzzled. You know, over here, it's very easy: You are either Catholic or Lutheran or maybe Reformed (in special areas on the coast). But then, in the aftermath of a lecture at our Old Boys Discussion Club at the church I got my hands on a book with 388 pages (index included) about all the denominations in the US and this handbook has opened my mind indeed.
Take care Herbert
Herbert & Bertl
Sorry about taking a while to reply. I think the differences between our countries in regard to church diversity go back to the founding of the United States. I read in history books that our country was settled by people seeking religious freedom from countries where the church was governmentally controlled. The last church denomination I worked for was founded by Swiss and Norweigian people who were frustrated by the governments control of the church. They saw people who did not believe in God promoted to the positions of priests and giving communion to other people who were not believers. They were forced to financially support the church by the government even though they saw gross mishandling of the church. These people moved to the US to establish a church free of goverment control. Now multiply that story by a couple hundred. With this new freedom from government control, many of these US churches spawned, or planted, other churches who believed things slightly differently. Even the smallest theological differences caused the generation of a new church. This produced the ridiculous number of denominations within the United States. One of the problems that lead to this fracturing was that individual churches decided that they would make their particular pet issues dogma or required beliefs to be a part of that church. Some of these pet issues were how the free will of man and the sovereignty(ultimate control) of God work together, How, when and where Jesus will return when he comes again, How God created the earth, How the Holy Spirit works or what it is that he does. Surely a church should have some central beliefs that define itself, but in my opinion the opinions of men were made dogma and thus caused the need for a person who disagrees with a particular point to leave and potentially start a new church. That after all was the genesis of the Lutheran church.
My desire to start a new church in light of what I've said seems a bit hypocritical, but my desire is to try to start a movement within the Church (all believers everywhere) to move towards the center of our belief (what has been agreed upon for centuries) and away from the periphery of our opinions. That isn't to say that opinions would not be present at this church I would like to create, rather that my opinions would not be taught as though they were unquestionable truth. I would also like the church to take on a position of helping people to think and determine what they believe for themselves rather than telling people what to believe.
I don't believe this will right all the wrongs of the past or be the final word on church. I just hope to move the eternal conversation on "what is church" ahead a baby step. The next generation will get to fix the short-sightedness and dangerous extremes of these thoughts, as always happens.
I bet the way in which people percieve their faith and understand the church would be different between our two countries as well. I would imagine the American view would be much more individualistic and less sunday church service focused and the German, I assume, would be more corporately focused and sunday service focused. Would you agree with that characterization of the German church? What is it like?
How did your visit with mom and dad go?
Kurt